An Effective Way to Give Student Feedback
Providing constructive feedback is an integral part of the learning process, especially for upper elementary students who are developing their skills and confidence. I love the “Glow and Grow” method because it is an effective strategy that balances positive reinforcement with areas for improvement. It fosters a growth mindset among students and provides them with a framework for learning to give feedback to their peers. Here are some tips for implementing the Glow and Grow method in your classroom to support your students’ academic and personal growth.
What is the Glow and Grow Method?
The Glow and Grow method is a two-part feedback system:
Glow: The “glow” portion of the feedback highlights what the student did well. This part of the feedback focuses on their strengths and achievements, boosting their confidence and reinforcing positive behaviors or skills. It is important to state this first.
Grow: The “grow” portion identifies areas where the student can improve. This part of the feedback encourages students to reflect on their performance and understand that learning is a continuous process. It is given second, after the glow.
How to Implement the Glow and Grow Method in Your Classroom
Prepare Your Feedback
Before giving feedback, take the time to review each student’s work. Look for specific examples of what they did well and areas that need improvement. Being specific is key to making your feedback meaningful and actionable.
Start with a Glow
Begin your feedback by pointing out the positive aspects of the student’s work. This sets a positive tone and shows students that you recognize and appreciate their efforts.
For example:
– “Your introduction was very engaging; it really drew me into your story.”
– “You did an excellent job solving the math problems using the correct order of operations.”
Introduce the Grow
After highlighting the student’s work’s strengths and positives, gently introduce areas for improvement. Phrase your feedback in a way that encourages growth rather than criticism.
For example:
– “To make your conclusion stronger, try summarizing the main points of your story.”
– “For the next set of problems, double-check your work to avoid small mistakes.”
Be Specific and Constructive with the Feedback
Vague feedback can leave students confused about how to improve. Instead, provide specific examples and actionable suggestions.
For instance:
– Instead of saying, “Your grammar needs work,” say, “Let’s focus on using correct punctuation in your sentences. For example, remember to place a period at the end of each sentence.”
– Instead of saying, “Your math work was incorrect,” say, “Check your work on problems 3 and 5. You might have missed a step in the process.”
Encourage Your Students to Self-Reflect
Teach and encourage your students to reflect on both the Glow and Grow feedback they have received. Ask questions like:
– “What part of your work are you most proud of?”
– “What strategies can you use to improve in the areas I mentioned?”
This helps students take ownership of their learning and develop their critical thinking skills.
Follow-Up
Feedback is an ongoing process. You may want to keep anecdotal records of your Glow and Grow feedback to see if students are learning from it. I find this especially important when giving feedback on subjects such as writing, where growth can be difficult to see at times. Provide additional support and praise their progress, reinforcing the idea that growth is a continual journey.
Benefits of the Glow and Grow Feedback Method
Builds Confidence
Starting with positive feedback helps build students’ confidence and motivates them to continue putting in effort.
Promotes a Growth Mindset
The “Grow” aspect encourages students to view challenges as opportunities for learning and development, rather than seeing mistakes as “bad.”
Creates a Positive Learning Environment
This method fosters a supportive and encouraging classroom atmosphere where students feel safe to take risks and make mistakes.
Enhances Communication Skills
By discussing both strengths and areas for improvement, you help students develop their ability to give and receive constructive feedback, a valuable skill for their future.
Individualizes Learning
The Glow and Grow method allows you to tailor feedback to each student’s unique strengths and needs, making your teaching more effective.
I hope that by incorporating the Glow and Grow method into your feedback routine can transform the way your upper elementary students perceive and respond to feedback. By highlighting their strengths and guiding them on areas for improvement, you empower them to become more self-aware, resilient, and motivated learners. Start using this method in your classroom and watch your students glow and grow!
If you are looking for an easy way to try the Glow and Grow Feedback Method, take a look at these Editable Glow and Grow Sticky Note Templates. They have everything you need to get started!
